Kaufman Trophy Properties

Kaufman Property Management

Client Testimonials

How much can I afford?

Moving Checklist

Auction Vs. Listing

How to bid at auctions

Auction Dictionary

Kaufman Quarterly

1 (888) 852-4111

Kaufman Trophy Properties

Kaufman Property Management

Client Testimonials

How much can I afford?

Moving Checklist

Auction Vs. Listing

How to bid at auctions

Auction Dictionary

Home/Auctions/Sports Cards, Rookie Cards, Complete Sets & More

Live & Online Auction

Sports Cards, Rookie Cards, Complete Sets & More

Sports Cards, Rookie Cards, Complete Sets & More

Sports Cards, Rookie Cards, Complete Sets & More

ONLINE ONLY

Simulcast Bidding Begins Monday August 17^th at 3:30 PM

SHIPPING IS AVAILABLE

Pick up will be on Tuesday August 18^th from 10:00 AM – 2:00 PM at the Kaufman Auction Center – 559 Belden Parkway Sugarcreek, OH 44681

1973 Topps baseball Starter Set| 1957-1958 Topps, Rocky Colavito | 1959 Topps baseball Cleveland Indians Team Set| 1995 Upper Deck SP Wayne Gretzky 2500 Career Points Card| 1992-93 Fleer All Star Weekend Michael Jordan Insert| Kobe Bryant, Fleer Metal Fresh Foundation, Rookie card | 1956 Topps Willie Mays #130 | 2025 Topps Chrome Treveyon Henderson First Year Card & More

Terms: There will be a 20% buyer’s premium added to the purchase of each item. Online Bidding Terms Apply.

Kaufman Realty & Auctions

888.852.4111

Auctioneer: Cliff Sprang, Auctioneer

(330)464-5155 or Cliff.sprang@kaufmanrealty.com

559 Belden Parkway, Sugarcreek, Ohio 44654

CATEGORY

Open

Sort By

Per Page

Page1of1

0 Lots Total

1972 Topps baseball Starter Set 160 cards, no duplicates, plus 5 Stars

Lot 1:1972 Topps baseball Starter Set 160 cards, no duplicates, plus 5 Stars

CURRENT BID

$12.00

Bids:

8

Watching:

7

1961 Topps baseball Starter Set, 43 cards, no duplicates, in order

Lot 2:1961 Topps baseball Starter Set, 43 cards, no duplicates, in order

CURRENT BID

$12.00

Bids:

7

Watching:

8

1973 Topps baseball Starter Set 228 cards, no duplicates, all in order

Lot 3:1973 Topps baseball Starter Set 228 cards, no duplicates, all in order

CURRENT BID

$10.00

Bids:

7

Watching:

10

1965 Topps baseball Starter Set 106 cards, no duplicates, all in order

Lot 4:1965 Topps baseball Starter Set 106 cards, no duplicates, all in order

CURRENT BID

$70.00

Bids:

19

Watching:

9

1972 Topps football Starter Set, 22 cards, no duplicates with 4 Stars: Unitas, Butkas, Staubach

Lot 5:1972 Topps football Starter Set, 22 cards, no duplicates with 4 Stars: Unitas, Butkas, Staubach

CURRENT BID

$12.00

Bids:

10

Watching:

9

1952 Bowman football Starter Set, Small 13 cards, no duplicates, all in order

Lot 6:1952 Bowman football Starter Set, Small 13 cards, no duplicates, all in order

CURRENT BID

$7.00

Bids:

7

Watching:

8

1970-1971 Topps basketball 80 cards, Stars & Rookies

Lot 7:1970-1971 Topps basketball 80 cards, Stars & Rookies

CURRENT BID

$30.00

Bids:

10

Watching:

10

1981 Topps Perma Graphics 32 card set, all in holders, many Stars

Lot 8:1981 Topps Perma Graphics 32 card set, all in holders, many Stars

CURRENT BID

$3.00

Bids:

3

Watching:

5

1966 Philadelphia football, Starter Set 17 cards, no duplicates, many Stars

Lot 9:1966 Philadelphia football, Starter Set 17 cards, no duplicates, many Stars

CURRENT BID

$18.00

Bids:

5

Watching:

7

1951 Berk Ross baseball 8 cards, no duplicates

Lot 10:1951 Berk Ross baseball 8 cards, no duplicates

CURRENT BID

$70.00

Bids:

16

Watching:

9

1965 Philadelphia football Starter Set, 19 cards, no duplicates, LeBeau & 8 other Rookies

Lot 11:1965 Philadelphia football Starter Set, 19 cards, no duplicates, LeBeau & 8 other Rookies

CURRENT BID

$22.00

Bids:

6

Watching:

7

1951 Bowman football, 7 cards, with Bill Dudley

Lot 12:1951 Bowman football, 7 cards, with Bill Dudley

CURRENT BID

$6.00

Bids:

3

Watching:

8

1952 Bowman Large football, 5 cards w/Dante Lavelli

Lot 13:1952 Bowman Large football, 5 cards w/Dante Lavelli

CURRENT BID

$35.00

Bids:

12

Watching:

9

1954 Bowman baseball, no duplicates, 9 cards

Lot 14:1954 Bowman baseball, no duplicates, 9 cards

CURRENT BID

$18.00

Bids:

12

Watching:

10

1954 Bowman baseball, no duplicates, 9 cards

Lot 15:1954 Bowman baseball, no duplicates, 9 cards

CURRENT BID

$14.00

Bids:

10

Watching:

8

1948 Leaf baseball: Andy Pafko, Mickey Harris, Hank Edwards

Lot 16:1948 Leaf baseball: Andy Pafko, Mickey Harris, Hank Edwards

CURRENT BID

$12.00

Bids:

7

Watching:

8

1961 Topps football, 14 cards w/Blanda, Ringo, Nomellini

Lot 17:1961 Topps football, 14 cards w/Blanda, Ringo, Nomellini

CURRENT BID

$16.00

Bids:

7

Watching:

8

1954 Dan-Dee Cleveland Indians: Jim Hegan & Dale Mitchell

Lot 18:1954 Dan-Dee Cleveland Indians: Jim Hegan & Dale Mitchell

CURRENT BID

$24.00

Bids:

15

Watching:

5

1961-1962 Fleer basketball 4 cards with 2 Rookies

Lot 19:1961-1962 Fleer basketball 4 cards with 2 Rookies

CURRENT BID

$5.00

Bids:

4

Watching:

7

1967 Topps baseball, 36 cards, no duplicates, plus Duke Sims, PSA/EX MT

Lot 20:1967 Topps baseball, 36 cards, no duplicates, plus Duke Sims, PSA/EX MT

CURRENT BID

$24.00

Bids:

8

Watching:

8

1973 Topps baseball 35 Stars, no duplicates

Lot 21:1973 Topps baseball 35 Stars, no duplicates

CURRENT BID

$2.00

Bids:

2

Watching:

10

1971 Topps baseball 5 cards: Simmons (Rookie) Stargell, Maz, Killebrew, B. Robinson

Lot 22:1971 Topps baseball 5 cards: Simmons (Rookie) Stargell, Maz, Killebrew, B. Robinson

CURRENT BID

$6.00

Bids:

5

Watching:

8

1971 Topps baseball : Brock, Kaline, Williams, McCovey

Lot 23:1971 Topps baseball : Brock, Kaline, Williams, McCovey

CURRENT BID

$3.00

Bids:

4

Watching:

8

1971 Topps baseball 6 pitchers, no duplicates,

Lot 24:1971 Topps baseball 6 pitchers, no duplicates,

CURRENT BID

$4.00

Bids:

3

Watching:

6

1958 Topps football, Starter Set of 47 w/Lenny Moore

Lot 25:1958 Topps football, Starter Set of 47 w/Lenny Moore

CURRENT BID

$18.00

Bids:

9

Watching:

8

1955 Bowman baseball 11 cards, no duplicates

Lot 26:1955 Bowman baseball 11 cards, no duplicates

CURRENT BID

$6.00

Bids:

3

Watching:

5

1955 Bowman football, 23 cards plus Groza,

Lot 27:1955 Bowman football, 23 cards plus Groza,

CURRENT BID

$7.00

Bids:

3

Watching:

9

1958 Topps baseball, all Cleveland Indians, 29 cards, no duplicates

Lot 28:1958 Topps baseball, all Cleveland Indians, 29 cards, no duplicates

CURRENT BID

$35.00

Bids:

12

Watching:

11

1957-1958 Topps, Rocky Colavito

Lot 29:1957-1958 Topps, Rocky Colavito

CURRENT BID

$10.00

Bids:

10

Watching:

8

1956 Topps football, all Cleveland Browns, 12 cards w/ Groza & Renfro

Lot 30:1956 Topps football, all Cleveland Browns, 12 cards w/ Groza & Renfro

CURRENT BID

$4.00

Bids:

3

Watching:

7

1969 Topps 7 cards Star lot w/ Gibson, Drysdale, Marichal plus others

Lot 31:1969 Topps 7 cards Star lot w/ Gibson, Drysdale, Marichal plus others

CURRENT BID

$10.00

Bids:

7

Watching:

8

1967 Topps baseball Stars 7 cards, w/Colavito SP

Lot 32:1967 Topps baseball Stars 7 cards, w/Colavito SP

CURRENT BID

$3.00

Bids:

3

Watching:

8

1964 Philadelphia Star lot: Unitas, Tittle, Gifford

Lot 33:1964 Philadelphia Star lot: Unitas, Tittle, Gifford

CURRENT BID

$1.00

Bids:

1

Watching:

6

1975 Topps baseball 20 card Star lot with no duplicates

Lot 34:1975 Topps baseball 20 card Star lot with no duplicates

CURRENT BID

$9.00

Bids:

4

Watching:

6

1952 Bowman baseball: Bob Lemon & Early Wynn

Lot 35:1952 Bowman baseball: Bob Lemon & Early Wynn

CURRENT BID

$6.00

Bids:

7

Watching:

8

1957 Topps baseball Cleveland Indians pitchers: Wynn, Lemon, Garcia, Score

Lot 36:1957 Topps baseball Cleveland Indians pitchers: Wynn, Lemon, Garcia, Score

CURRENT BID

$12.00

Bids:

13

Watching:

9

Parker Messick signed Rookie card Topps Chrome, JSA

Lot 37:Parker Messick signed Rookie card Topps Chrome, JSA

CURRENT BID

$9.00

Bids:

9

Watching:

8

1959 Topps baseball 53 card Starter Lot, no duplicates, in order

Lot 38:1959 Topps baseball 53 card Starter Lot, no duplicates, in order

CURRENT BID

$60.00

Bids:

13

Watching:

11

1987 Topps baseball Vending boxes, sealed, total of 2, many Rookies and Stars

Lot 39:1987 Topps baseball Vending boxes, sealed, total of 2, many Rookies and Stars

CURRENT BID

$24.00

Bids:

13

Watching:

8

1957 Topps baseball Starter Set, 75 cards, no duplicates, in order

Lot 40:1957 Topps baseball Starter Set, 75 cards, no duplicates, in order

CURRENT BID

$80.00

Bids:

20

Watching:

11

1957 Topps baseball Starter Set, 65 cards, in order, no duplicates

Lot 41:1957 Topps baseball Starter Set, 65 cards, in order, no duplicates

CURRENT BID

$80.00

Bids:

14

Watching:

9

1970s Topps vintage basketball, 80 cards, Stars & Rookies

Lot 42:1970s Topps vintage basketball, 80 cards, Stars & Rookies

CURRENT BID

$6.00

Bids:

3

Watching:

6

1953 Topps baseball 10 cards, no duplicates

Lot 43:1953 Topps baseball 10 cards, no duplicates

CURRENT BID

$22.00

Bids:

10

Watching:

7

1950 Bowman Starter Set of 20, no duplicates, in holders

Lot 44:1950 Bowman Starter Set of 20, no duplicates, in holders

CURRENT BID

$45.00

Bids:

9

Watching:

8

1959 Topps baseball Cleveland Indians Team Set, no duplicates

Lot 45:1959 Topps baseball Cleveland Indians Team Set, no duplicates

CURRENT BID

$40.00

Bids:

16

Watching:

10

Panini full count swatches: Andre Dawson, Luke Appling, Gil McDougald

Lot 46:Panini full count swatches: Andre Dawson, Luke Appling, Gil McDougald

CURRENT BID

$12.00

Bids:

10

Watching:

5

Panini full count swatches: Rod Carew, Alfonso Soriano, Elroy Jimmenez

Lot 47:Panini full count swatches: Rod Carew, Alfonso Soriano, Elroy Jimmenez

CURRENT BID

$16.00

Bids:

12

Watching:

7

Panini full count swatches: Joe Morgan, Chris Mullens, Andres Galarraga

Lot 48:Panini full count swatches: Joe Morgan, Chris Mullens, Andres Galarraga

CURRENT BID

$16.00

Bids:

11

Watching:

7

Michael Jordan card lot of 24, no duplicates, some inserts

Lot 49:Michael Jordan card lot of 24, no duplicates, some inserts

CURRENT BID

$65.00

Bids:

14

Watching:

15

Michael Jordan , Fleer Metal, Rookie baseball set & 90 Fleer All-Star set

Lot 50:Michael Jordan , Fleer Metal, Rookie baseball set & 90 Fleer All-Star set

CURRENT BID

$35.00

Bids:

15

Watching:

13

26 Card- Michael Jordan Lot

Lot 51:26 Card- Michael Jordan Lot

CURRENT BID

$75.00

Bids:

21

Watching:

13

14 Card- Shaquille O'Neal Lot- Rookies

Lot 52:14 Card- Shaquille O'Neal Lot- Rookies

CURRENT BID

$5.00

Bids:

5

Watching:

11

8 Card Alonzo Mourning Rookie Lot

Lot 53:8 Card Alonzo Mourning Rookie Lot

CURRENT BID

$1.00

Bids:

1

Watching:

2

8 Card- 1990 Hopps Sam Vincent Lot/Featuring Michael Jordan #12

Lot 54:8 Card- 1990 Hopps Sam Vincent Lot/Featuring Michael Jordan #12

CURRENT BID

$2.00

Bids:

2

Watching:

8

$7 Card- Topps Finest Basketball Refractor Lot$

Lot 55:7 Card- Topps Finest Basketball Refractor Lot

CURRENT BID

$3.00

Bids:

3

Watching:

5

3 Card- 1988 Fleer Dennis Rodman Rookie Card Lot

Lot 56:3 Card- 1988 Fleer Dennis Rodman Rookie Card Lot

CURRENT BID

$12.00

Bids:

5

Watching:

11

18 Card - Skybox X-cited Lot w/ HOFers

Lot 57:18 Card - Skybox X-cited Lot w/ HOFers

CURRENT BID

$5.00

Bids:

5

Watching:

3

28 Card- 1990's Insert Basketbal Card Lot- W/HOFERs

Lot 58:28 Card- 1990's Insert Basketbal Card Lot- W/HOFERs

CURRENT BID

$2.00

Bids:

2

Watching:

5

9- Card- Basketball Rookie Card Lot- HOFers

Lot 59:9- Card- Basketball Rookie Card Lot- HOFers

CURRENT BID

$25.00

Bids:

7

Watching:

9

8 Card- 1994 E-Motion N-Tense Lot- W/Hofers

Lot 60:8 Card- 1994 E-Motion N-Tense Lot- W/Hofers

CURRENT BID

$1.00

Bids:

1

Watching:

3

22 Card- 1990's Baseball Insert Lot- W HOFers

Lot 61:22 Card- 1990's Baseball Insert Lot- W HOFers

CURRENT BID

$1.00

Bids:

1

Watching:

3

10 Card- 1995 Fleer Flair Hot Numbers Insert Set- WHOFers

Lot 62:10 Card- 1995 Fleer Flair Hot Numbers Insert Set- WHOFers

CURRENT BID

$1.00

Bids:

1

Watching:

3

6 Card- Greg Maddux Lot- W/ Rookie Cards and Inserts

Lot 63:6 Card- Greg Maddux Lot- W/ Rookie Cards and Inserts

CURRENT BID

$2.00

Bids:

2

Watching:

5

8- Card Alex Rodriguez Rookie card Lot

Lot 64:8- Card Alex Rodriguez Rookie card Lot

CURRENT BID

$2.00

Bids:

2

Watching:

7

12 Card- Frank Thomas Lot w/Rookies and Inserts

Lot 65:12 Card- Frank Thomas Lot w/Rookies and Inserts

CURRENT BID

$1.00

Bids:

1

Watching:

6

1996 Score Sample Lot- Derek Jeter Rookie Cards includes Dugout Coll.

Lot 66:1996 Score Sample Lot- Derek Jeter Rookie Cards includes Dugout Coll.

CURRENT BID

$2.00

Bids:

2

Watching:

7

4 Card Select Four - Select Certified Insert Lot- Very Difficult to Find

Lot 67:4 Card Select Four - Select Certified Insert Lot- Very Difficult to Find

CURRENT BID

$2.00

Bids:

2

Watching:

3

10 Card 1994 Fleer Flair Hot Numbers Lot- W HOFers

Lot 68:10 Card 1994 Fleer Flair Hot Numbers Lot- W HOFers

CURRENT BID

$0.00

Bids:

0

Watching:

1

3 Card Fleer Flair Football Hot Numbers Lot- W/HOFers

Lot 69:3 Card Fleer Flair Football Hot Numbers Lot- W/HOFers

CURRENT BID

$0.00

Bids:

0

Watching:

1

13 Card- 1990's NFL Insert and Rookies Lot- Marino, Favre, Smith

Lot 70:13 Card- 1990's NFL Insert and Rookies Lot- Marino, Favre, Smith

CURRENT BID

$2.00

Bids:

2

Watching:

6

7 Card- Marshall Faulk Rookie Card Lot

Lot 71:7 Card- Marshall Faulk Rookie Card Lot

CURRENT BID

$2.00

Bids:

2

Watching:

4

4 Card Drew Bledsoe Rookie Card Lot- Includes 2 1993 SP Rookie Cards

Lot 72:4 Card Drew Bledsoe Rookie Card Lot- Includes 2 1993 SP Rookie Cards

CURRENT BID

$0.00

Bids:

0

Watching:

1

3 Card 1990's Hockey Insert Lot

Lot 73:3 Card 1990's Hockey Insert Lot

CURRENT BID

$0.00

Bids:

0

Watching:

1

1995 Upper Deck SP Wayne Gretzky 2500 Career Points Card

Lot 74:1995 Upper Deck SP Wayne Gretzky 2500 Career Points Card

CURRENT BID

$1.00

Bids:

1

Watching:

5

1992 Hopps NBA Dream Team USA Basketball Card

Lot 75:1992 Hopps NBA Dream Team USA Basketball Card

CURRENT BID

$2.00

Bids:

2

Watching:

6

1994 SP Die cut Red Holo Mark McGwire

Lot 76:1994 SP Die cut Red Holo Mark McGwire

CURRENT BID

$1.00

Bids:

1

Watching:

3

1996 Stadium Club Kobe Bryant Rookie Card

Lot 77:1996 Stadium Club Kobe Bryant Rookie Card

CURRENT BID

$35.00

Bids:

4

Watching:

13

1991 Upper Deck Michael Jordan Baseball SP1

Lot 78:1991 Upper Deck Michael Jordan Baseball SP1

CURRENT BID

$30.00

Bids:

13

Watching:

11

1994 Upper Deck Michael Jordan Baseball Insert /15,000

Lot 79:1994 Upper Deck Michael Jordan Baseball Insert /15,000

CURRENT BID

$4.00

Bids:

3

Watching:

12

1992-93 Fleer All Star Weekend Michael Jordan Insert

Lot 80:1992-93 Fleer All Star Weekend Michael Jordan Insert

CURRENT BID

$12.00

Bids:

5

Watching:

12

Upper Deck SP Die Cut Nolan Ryan

Lot 81:Upper Deck SP Die Cut Nolan Ryan

CURRENT BID

$2.00

Bids:

2

Watching:

3

Upper Deck Be A Player Patrick Roy Autographed Card

Lot 82:Upper Deck Be A Player Patrick Roy Autographed Card

CURRENT BID

$7.00

Bids:

5

Watching:

4

Upper deck Be a Player Die Cut Alexander DaigleAutographed card

Lot 83:Upper deck Be a Player Die Cut Alexander DaigleAutographed card

CURRENT BID

$2.00

Bids:

2

Watching:

3

1992 Leaf Frank Thomas Autographed Card- 1967/3500

Lot 84:1992 Leaf Frank Thomas Autographed Card- 1967/3500

CURRENT BID

$18.00

Bids:

14

Watching:

10

1992 Bowman Baseball Complete Set- Piazza, Pedro Martinez RC's

Lot 85:1992 Bowman Baseball Complete Set- Piazza, Pedro Martinez RC's

CURRENT BID

$2.00

Bids:

2

Watching:

6

1994 Bowman Baseball Complete Set- Foil Jeter

Lot 86:1994 Bowman Baseball Complete Set- Foil Jeter

CURRENT BID

$5.00

Bids:

5

Watching:

6

1994 Bowman's Best Complete Set

Lot 87:1994 Bowman's Best Complete Set

CURRENT BID

$22.00

Bids:

10

Watching:

4

1995 Premier Upper Deck Die Cut Basketball Set- Kidd RC

Lot 88:1995 Premier Upper Deck Die Cut Basketball Set- Kidd RC

CURRENT BID

$1.00

Bids:

1

Watching:

4

1995 Premier Upper Deck Base Basketball Set- Kidd RC

Lot 89:1995 Premier Upper Deck Base Basketball Set- Kidd RC

CURRENT BID

$1.00

Bids:

1

Watching:

3

1994-95 SP Championship Series Die Cut Basketball Set- Jordan

Lot 90:1994-95 SP Championship Series Die Cut Basketball Set- Jordan

CURRENT BID

$6.00

Bids:

5

Watching:

10

1994-95 SP Championship Series Base Basketball Set- Jordan

Lot 91:1994-95 SP Championship Series Base Basketball Set- Jordan

CURRENT BID

$4.00

Bids:

3

Watching:

8

62 Card- 1994 Hoops Power Predator Lot- W/ HOFers- Shaq, Pippen

Lot 92:62 Card- 1994 Hoops Power Predator Lot- W/ HOFers- Shaq, Pippen

CURRENT BID

$3.00

Bids:

3

Watching:

3

1995-1995 Magic's All Rookie Team Set- Kidd Rookie

Lot 93:1995-1995 Magic's All Rookie Team Set- Kidd Rookie

CURRENT BID

$1.00

Bids:

1

Watching:

2

18 Card- Fleer Total D- Insert Set Lot- Olajuwon, Robinson, Rodman

Lot 94:18 Card- Fleer Total D- Insert Set Lot- Olajuwon, Robinson, Rodman

CURRENT BID

$1.00

Bids:

1

Watching:

3

1994 E-Motion Basketball Set- Jordan

Lot 95:1994 E-Motion Basketball Set- Jordan

CURRENT BID

$9.00

Bids:

7

Watching:

8

1994 Hoops Tip-Off Dream Team Complete Set

Lot 96:1994 Hoops Tip-Off Dream Team Complete Set

CURRENT BID

$2.00

Bids:

2

Watching:

6

1993 Fleer Tower of Power Basketball Complete Insert Set

Lot 97:1993 Fleer Tower of Power Basketball Complete Insert Set

CURRENT BID

$0.00

Bids:

0

Watching:

2

1994 Hoops Magic's All Rookie Team Oversized Set- Kidd RC

Lot 98:1994 Hoops Magic's All Rookie Team Oversized Set- Kidd RC

CURRENT BID

$1.00

Bids:

1

Watching:

2

1993 Finest Complete Basketball Set

Lot 99:1993 Finest Complete Basketball Set

CURRENT BID

$80.00

Bids:

13

Watching:

9

1994 Leaf Limited Baseball Complete Set

Lot 100:1994 Leaf Limited Baseball Complete Set

CURRENT BID

$2.00

Bids:

2

Watching:

3

Per Page

Page1of1

1 (888) 852 4111

Terms & Conditions

ADA Accessibility Policy

WEEKLY AUCTION EMAIL SIGN UP

Join our email list and never miss a sale!

SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTER

© Copyright 2026 Kaufman Realty & Auctions